James K.'s Wake-Up Call: The Hidden Risk of Relying Too Much on Your Pension

For many professors, the promise of a pension provides a sense of security—sometimes too much security. The assumption that a steady monthly check from a pension or Social Security will be enough to cover all retirement expenses often leads to financial miscalculations. James K., a 60-year-old tenured professor, learned this lesson the hard way, but luckily he sought out help before it was too late.

The Illusion of Financial Security

James K. has spent over 35 years in academia. Like many faculty members, he believed his university’s pension plan, combined with Social Security, would be more than enough for a comfortable retirement. Over the years, he contributed steadily to his pension without calculating his nest egg needed when he retired. As a result, he never felt the need to invest in additional retirement savings options like a 403(b) or IRA.

James expected to receive $3,200 per month from his pension and an additional $2,000 from Social Security—a total of $5,200 per month. With his house paid off, no major debts, and a current monthly living expense of $5,167 he figured he was set.

Financial Snapshot: James’s Income, Assets, and Expenses

The Reality Check: Finding the Income Gap

As James neared retirement, he reached out to a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) to assess his readiness. The CFP conducted a detailed analysis and quickly identified an income gap.

James’ total expected monthly income was $5,200 ($3,200 pension + $2,000 Social Security). However, his estimated monthly expenses were $5,167. On the surface, this looks sufficient. But when factoring in healthcare costs of $667 per month ($8,000 annually), his actual expense total was $5,834 per month.

Income Gap Calculation:

Without additional savings or income sources, James would need to cover an annual shortfall of $7,608.

Filling the Income Gap: The CFP’s Recommendations

After analyzing James' situation, the CFP provided real-dollar solutions to close the income gap and maintain his desired lifestyle:

1. Increase Retirement Contributions Before Retiring

James had seven years before his planned retirement at 67. The CFP recommended increasing his 403(b) contributions by saving $1,500 per month, adding approximately $126,000 to his savings before retirement.

2. Optimize His 403(b) and IRA Withdrawals

With his current savings of $150,000 in a 403(b) and $50,000 in an IRA, plus his increased contributions, the CFP advised following a structured withdrawal plan. Using the 4% rule, James could withdraw approximately $13,000 annually from his accounts.

3. Delay Social Security for a Higher Payout

By delaying Social Security until age 70, James could increase his monthly benefit from $2,000 to $2,480, providing an extra $5,760 per year.

4. Consider Part-Time Teaching

James enjoyed teaching and agreed to take on a part-time adjunct position, earning $10,000 per year for the first five years of retirement to supplement his income.

Projected Financial Outcome

With these adjustments, James' new estimated monthly retirement income at age 70 would be:

Updated Summary: Closing the Financial Gaps

• Additional Monthly Savings Before Retirement: James will contribute $1,500 per month for the next seven years, adding $126,000 to his retirement accounts.
• Healthcare Costs Consideration: Estimated at $8,000 per year, which must be planned for within his withdrawals and Social Security benefits.

Final Thoughts: Building a Comprehensive Retirement Plan

By working with a CFP, James transformed his retirement outlook. Instead of facing an income shortfall, he now has a structured plan with diversified income streams to maintain his desired lifestyle. Professors should take a proactive approach by consulting a CFP early, evaluating all potential income sources, and making informed financial decisions well before retirement.

James’ story highlights the importance of strategic retirement planning. By implementing similar strategies, professors can secure a comfortable and financially stable future.

Intermountain Wealth Management is a Registered Investment Adviser (RIA). The company manages several fee-based portfolios comprised of various equity and fixed-income investments that may include exchange traded funds (ETF’s), stocks and mutual funds. This is not a prospectus or an offer to sell any security.  Please read the prospectus of any investment before you invest. The information included here is intended for education and information purposes only.